NewsEducationEducation NewsWhite private schoolboys ‘are disadvantaged group due to culture war’ Cambridge academic claims

Historian says school names should ‘probably’ be removed from application forms to avoid this

Zoe TidmanFriday 13 May 2022 11:47Comments Article bookmarked

Find your bookmarks in your Independent Premium section, under my profile

Don't show me this message again✕

David Abulafia made the comments in a piece in The Spectator

(Marit Hommedal/SCANPIX/Holbergprisen/CC BY 2.0)

White boys from top private schools are the “disadvantaged candidates” when applying to Oxbridge as their traits get targeted in culture wars, a Cambridge academic has said.

David Abulafia, a British historian, claimed their characteristics were being used to “justify injustice” as peers from state schools take top university places instead.

Oxford University says its intake from UK state schools stood at just over 68 per cent in 2021 - up from 58 per cent in 2017.

Meanwhile Cambridge University says around 69 per cent of its undergraduates came from state schools in 2020 compared to 31 per cent from private schools, according to the latest available data.

It is estimated just 6.5 per cent of school pupils in the UK are educated at private schools.

Recommended

• Next Oxford University vice-chancellor state educated and second female in role
• Oxford University to fund graduate scholarships from Ukraine
• Brexit blamed for fall in numbers of EU students at Oxford

But Mr Abulafia from Cambridge University argued these students were being unfairly discriminated against in application processes for top universities attempting to balance out this split.

In an article in The Spectator, the emeritus professor of Mediterranean history used Eton as an example.

“Although Eton is one of the top academic schools in the country, its ‘beaks’ are puzzled by the sharp reduction in the number of their brightest pupils gaining places at Oxbridge. The number of offers has halved between 2014 and 2021,” he wrote.

“At the moment the really disadvantaged candidates are arguably the white males from outstanding independent schools. If they are rejected by their first-choice college and placed in the ‘pool’ so other colleges can look at their application, they nearly all sink without trace.”

Recommended

• Fears of ‘glaring loopholes’ in crackdown on Putin’s allies sending children to UK private schools
• How ‘soft bigotry’ of teachers’ low expectations is stopping poor pupils going to university
• Private school pupils likely to ‘elbow out’ state students in scramble for university places, experts warn

He said: “University admissions have become another site for culture wars in which ‘white’, ‘male’ and ‘privileged’ are terms of disapproval, linked together to justify injustice. Imagined class must not determine admissions.

“School names should probably be omitted from application forms. Penalising applicants for their parents’ choice of school ‘strips the pupil of any agency’, to quote one distinguished head.”

(function({ document }) { var script = document.createElement('script'); script.defer = 'true'; script.onload = function () { pixelsInsert && pixelsInsert('playinc-article-component-10').setup({ customparams: 'article%3D2078219%26gs_channels%3Desi_safe%2Csafe_from_essence_blacklist%2Cshadow9hu7_pos_ttd_uk_blocklist_mar21%2Cgs_education%2Csafe_from_emirates_blacklist%2Cgv_safe_adult%2Cgv_safe_arms%2Cgv_safe_crime%2Cgv_safe_death_injury%2Cgv_safe_download%2Cgv_safe_drugs%2Cgv_safe_hatespeech%2Cgv_safe_military%2Cgv_safe_obscenity%2Cgv_safe_terrorism%2Cgv_safe_tobacco%2Cpos_amazon_carnival_row_04%2Cpos_amex_2020%2Cpos_amex_blocklist_sep21%2Cpos_animal_cruelty%2Cpos_audi_oct20%2Cpos_bp%2Cpos_burberry%2Cpos_cartier1_usa%2Cpos_cartier2_usa%2Cpos_cartier3_usa%2Cpos_cartier4_usa%2Cpos_cartier5_usa%2Cpos_castrol_nov20%2Cpos_churchs%2Cpos_collective_ukrainerussia%2Cpos_covid19_leicester%2Cpos_creedfragrance_ladiesfragrance%2Cpos_equinor%2Cpos_facebook%2Cpos_facebook_oct20%2Cpos_facebook_policy_affairs%2Cpos_givenchy_kenny%2Cpos_heinz_blacklist_jul21_01%2Cpos_hsbc_oct20%2Cpos_inskin_safe%2Cpos_intel_evo_vpro_lob_q2%2Cpos_intel_feb21%2Cpos_inteluklobq1%2Cpos_jp_morgan_global_growth_income_h1%2Cpos_justpremium_cheltenham%2Cpos_loopme_negkeywords_2020%2Cpos_lvmh%2Cpos_mfk%2Cpos_microsoft_kwlist_jul21_01%2Cpos_microsoft_kwlist_jul21_02%2Cpos_microsoft_kwlist_jul21_03%2Cpos_microsoft_kwlist_jul21_04%2Cpos_microsoft_kwlist_jul21_05%2Cpos_microsoft_kwlist_jul21_06%2Cpos_microsoft_kwlist_jul21_07%2Cpos_o2_havas_jan21%2Cpos_philip_morris%2Cpos_philip_morris_1%2Cpos_philip_morris_10%2Cpos_philip_morris_11%2Cpos_philip_morris_12%2Cpos_philip_morris_13%2Cpos_philip_morris_14%2Cpos_philip_morris_15%2Cpos_philip_morris_17%2Cpos_philip_morris_18%2Cpos_philip_morris_19%2Cpos_philip_morris_2%2Cpos_philip_morris_20%2Cpos_philip_morris_3%2Cpos_philip_morris_4%2Cpos_philip_morris_5%2Cpos_philip_morris_6%2Cpos_philip_morris_7%2Cpos_philip_morris_8%2Cpos_philip_morris_9%2Cpos_rezonence_avanti%2Cpos_sabic%2Cpos_sabic_mobkoi%2Cpos_saudiaramco_nov20%2Cpos_society_lgbt%2Cpos_terrorism_blacklist%2Cpos_tesco_groupm_gps_nov20%2Cpos_test%2Cpos_tourismireland%2Cpos_uber%2Cpos_ukraine_war%2Cpos_valentino%2Cpos_vw_2020%2Cpos_vw_audi_ias_kw_list_jan21%2Cpos_vw_porsche_ias_kw_list_jan21%2Cpos_vw_seat_ias_kw_list_jan21%2Cpos_vw_skoda_ias_kw_list_jan21%2Cpos_vw_vwcv_man_vwfs_ias_kw_list_jan21%2Cpos_workhuman%2Cpos_worldwildlifefund_november20%2Cpos_zenithdefyskyline%2Csafe_from_aegis_blacklist%2Csafe_from_facebook_blacklist%2Csafe_from_mobkoi_facebook_keyword%2Cgs_education_university%2Cgs_education_misc%2Cshadow9hu7_pos_diageo_nov20%2Cshadow9hu7_pos_loop_me%2Cshadow9hu7_safe_from_asda%2Cshadow9hu7_pos_sukin_jan21%2Capple_corevalues_negkeywords_2020%2Cshadow9hu7_pos_collective_december2020%2Cgt_mixed%2Cshadow9hu7_pos_lg_aug20%2Cshadow9hu7_pos_philip_morris_16%2Cshadow9hu7_pos_t10_tanqueray%2Cshadow9hu7_pos_tanqueray_4000kw%2Cshadow9hu7_pos_keyword_blacklist_microsoft%2Cshadow9hu7_pos_hoopla_next_mar21%2Cgv_safe%26topictags%3Doxford-university%2Ccambridge%2Coxbridge%2Cculture-wars%2Cs_news%2Cs_education%2Cs_education-news', dunit: '71347885/_main_independent/in_news/in_education/video/article_hub', path: '/news/education/education-news/culture-war-david-abulafia-cambridge-b2078219.html', mediaid: '', title: 'White%20private%20schoolboys%20%E2%80%98are%20disadvantaged%20group%20due%20to%20culture%20war%E2%80%99%20Cambridge%20academic%20claims', text: 'Historian%20says%20school%20names%20should%20%E2%80%98probably%E2%80%99%20be%20removed%20from%20application%20forms%20to%20avoid%20this%20', tags: 'oxford-university,cambridge,oxbridge,culture-wars,s_news,s_education,s_education-news', domain: 'independent', version: '5', }); }; script.src = 'https://pub.pixels.ai/insert-lib.js'; document.head.appendChild(script); })(window);

The comments come just days after the Cambridge University vice-chancellor told The Times private schools will have to accept they will get fewer students into Oxbridge as the universities make an effort to attract students from all backgrounds.

“Individual students who are talented, we would want them,” Professor Stephen Toope told the newspaper, “but they’re going to be competing against an ever-larger pool because there are more students coming from state schools who are seeing a potential place for themselves at Cambridge or Oxford or other Russell Group universities.”

But last year’s A level results sparked alarm about a “widening socio-economic divide” as private schools saw a much greater jump in the proportion of students receiving top grades.

“On the basis of the results, my worry is that some disadvantaged students won’t get into the highly prestigious courses, and will be elbowed out by those from privileged backgrounds,” Dr Lee Elliot Major, professor of social mobility at Exeter University, told The Independent at the time.

Both Oxford and Cambridge University have been approached for comment.

Register for free to continue reading

Registration is a free and easy way to support our truly independent journalism

By registering, you will also enjoy limited access to Premium articles, exclusive newsletters, commenting, and virtual events with our leading journalists

registerEmailPlease enter a valid emailPlease enter a valid emailPasswordMust be at least 6 characters, include an upper and lower case character and a numberMust be at least 6 characters, include an upper and lower case character and a numberMust be at least 6 characters, include an upper and lower case character and a numberFirst namePlease enter your first nameSpecial characters aren’t allowedPlease enter a name between 1 and 40 charactersLast namePlease enter your last nameSpecial characters aren’t allowedPlease enter a name between 1 and 40 charactersSelect your year of birth2004200320022001200019991998199719961995199419931992199119901989198819871986198519841983198219811980197919781977197619751974197319721971197019691968196719661965196419631962196119601959195819571956195519541953195219511950194919481947194619451944194319421941194019391938193719361935193419331932193119301929192819271926192519241923192219211920191919181917191619151914You must be over 18 years old to registerYou must be over 18 years old to registerYear of birthI would like to be emailed about offers, events and updates from The Independent. 
Read our Privacy noticeOpt-out-policyYou can opt-out at any time by signing in to your account to manage your preferences. Each email has a link to unsubscribe.

{{#verifyErrors}} {{message}} {{/verifyErrors}} {{^verifyErrors}} {{message}} {{/verifyErrors}}

Create my account

By clicking ‘Create my account’ you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use, Cookie policy and Privacy notice.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy policy and Terms of service apply.

RegisterI'll try later

Already have an account? sign in

By clicking ‘Register’ you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use, Cookie policy and Privacy notice.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy policy and Terms of service apply.

More aboutOxford UniversityCambridgeOxbridgeculture wars Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments {"currentIndex":0}1/1White private school boys ‘are disadvantaged group due to culture war’ White private school boys ‘are disadvantaged group due to culture war’

David Abulafia made the comments in a piece in The Spectator

Marit Hommedal/SCANPIX/Holbergprisen/CC BY 2.0

✕Subscribe to Independent Premium to bookmark this article

Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Premium subscription today.

SubscribeAlready subscribed? Log inMost popular{{#link}}{{title}}{{/link}}Popular videos{{#link}} {{title}}{{/link}} {{#url}}{{short_headline}}{{/url}}Sponsored Features{{#link}}{{title}}{{/link}}Voucher CodesVery Discount CodeAt least 20% off electricals in the Very saleBooking Com DiscountsGetaway Deals up to 15% off with Booking.com in MayDebenhams Discount CodeFree UK delivery - Get £5 off orders worth £60 with this Debenhams voucher codeAliexpress Promo CodeGet 10% off selected orders using this AliExpress discount codeeBay Discount Code15% off selected orders over £15 with this eBay voucher codeIndy / CompareCompare the Best Broadband Deals in the UKCompare broadband packages side by side to find the best deal for youCheap Broadband Deals in 2022Compare cheap broadband deals from providers with fastest speed in your areaFibre Broadband DealsAll you need to know about fibre broadbandBest iPhone dealsCompare the Apple contracts and get the latest iPhone offersCompare Mobile Phone DealsCompare the best mobile phone deals from the top networks and brands